Was the Ketoret a Drug? The Ketoret as a Pharmacological Stack in the Search for Consciousness

Was the ketoret a drug? Eleven ingredients, exact weights down to the maneh, and a processing step where the Talmud casually admits urine works better than wine — and uses the worse one anyway. If someone handed you that spec sheet today, you wouldn’t call it a recipe. You’d call it a stack — biohacker language for compounds engineered together to hit multiple receptors at once, because no single ingredient carries the whole effect alone.

The Temple got there twenty-five centuries early. Incense instead of capsules, priests instead of a supplement aisle, and a family — the Avtinas — who guarded the formula the way a supplement company guards a “proprietary blend.” Which is exactly what it was.

Let’s take the ketoret seriously as what it actually looks like: a formula, because formulas don’t fall out of the sky.

Eleven Ingredients, Zero Guesswork

Seventy maneh each of balsam, onycha, galbanum, frankincense. Sixteen of myrrh, cassia, spikenard, saffron. Twelve of costus, nine of cinnamon, three of aromatic bark. That’s not seasoning. That’s dosing — different amounts for different compounds, tuned individually. And one ingredient whose identity the family took to their graves rather than write down.

You don’t guard a recipe that hard if it’s just incense.

This Was Insanely Expensive

Quick gut check before we go further: four of these eleven were, independently, among the priciest substances in the ancient world. Frankincense and myrrh traded near gold prices. Balsam — if it’s the real Balm of Gilead — reportedly sold at double the price of gold. Spikenard is the same nard poured on Jesus’ feet in John 12, valued at a year’s wages. Saffron is still the most expensive spice on Earth.

Burned twice a day. Every day. For centuries. Not a recipe — a standing line item only a serious temple economy could sustain.

Someone Was Testing This, Not Guessing

Before the onycha went in, it got soaked — wine or urine, the Talmud says plainly, and notes urine actually pulls more fragrance out. Rejected anyway, on propriety, not efficacy. That’s not ritual. That’s someone who ran the comparison, knew which worked better, and chose the worse one on purpose for reasons that had nothing to do with chemistry.

A thought experiment, not a claim: somewhere in the first century, a priest in Jerusalem is testing wine against urine. Meanwhile a Greek army doctor named Dioscorides is writing that onycha smells like castoreum when burned — he’s one of the actual sources for what onycha even was. They never met. The Second Temple fell in 70 CE; Dioscorides was writing between 50 and 70 CE. They may have been exact contemporaries. Throw in Carl Ruck, two thousand years early, muttering about ergot at the same imaginary urinal — full time-warp, and it knows it — and you’ve got three people across two millennia landing on the same method: test it on the body, compare it to the alternative, write down what happened.

That’s not mysticism. That’s just the scientific method showing up wherever people pay attention to their own smoke.

The lye trick wasn’t unique to Jerusalem. This is the exact chemistry now shown to turn deadly ergot into something usable — proposed for decades as the secret of the kykeon, Demeter’s own sacrament. Temple and kykeon, unconnected traditions, same solution to the same problem. Whether Eleusis actually used it is still debated. That the method works isn’t debated anymore. It’s published.

A stack isn’t just the ingredients. It’s the process for making them usable. The ketoret had one. Turns out the kykeon did too.

Egypt Already Had This: Kyphi

Kyphi has one thing the ketoret doesn’t: calamus, sweet flag, which brings β-asarone to the table — a compound structurally close to MDA, with real documented CNS-depressant and anticonvulsant activity, and a long folk reputation (unconfirmed clinically) as a hallucinogen.

And calamus might already be sitting four verses before the ketoret recipe even starts. Exodus 30:23 lists kaneh bosem in the holy anointing oil. Since 1936, a minority of scholars have argued that’s not calamus at all — it’s cannabis. Two live controversies, four verses apart, in the same chapter. We already know cannabis was physically burning in Judahite worship — Tel Arad had it on an altar. Oil and smoke: two delivery systems, one intention.

This isn’t academic history anymore, either. Walk into any legal CBD shop and you can buy “holy anointing oil” rebuilt from Exodus 30, hemp standing in for kaneh bosem. Transdermal cannabinoids genuinely absorb through skin and hit real receptors — no smoke, no digestion required. So no, hash oil was never just for brownies. That was the twentieth-century detour. Skin-first was the original delivery method, and it’s back on shelves with a barcode.

Persia’s Answer Never Stopped: The Zoroastrian fire Ritual, the Boi

Zoroastrian priests feed frankincense and sandalwood to a sacred fire five times a day, every day — a ritual called boi, which just means “fragrance.” Same core move as the ketoret: aromatic smoke, fixed schedule, sacred technology, not decoration. Difference is the ketoret stopped when the Temple fell. The Zoroastrian fire hasn’t — it’s been running, unbroken, since before Alexander, and it’s burning again right now, somewhere, as you read this.

Cannabis Was Already in Judah

We know Judah’s part isn’t speculation — the dig proved it. At Tel Arad, a fortress shrine built like a pocket-sized Temple, two altars sat at the threshold. Frankincense on the big one. Cannabis on the small one. Eighth century BCE, burning in front of a Holy of Holies.

If this was moving through the ancient Near East, the obvious next question is where it came from — or went. The Pamir Plateau sits at the crossroads connecting China, Central Asia, and everywhere west: the exact corridor later formalized as the Silk Road.

Jirzankal: Cannabis and the Dead

Around 500 BCE, ten wooden braziers from eight tombs at Jirzankal tested positive for cannabinoid residue — specifically CBN, the burned signature of high-THC cannabis. Earliest scientifically confirmed evidence anywhere on Earth of cannabis smoked for its psychoactive effect.

Not an isolated grave, either. A third of the buried individuals were migrants, well above the regional baseline. Chinese silk. Western Asian glass and harps. And the paper that found the cannabis is the same paper describing the Pamir corridor as active “before the establishment of Han governmental regulation” — meaning the Silk Road may be older than the Silk Road.

Put Jirzankal next to Tel Arad: ritual cannabis in the Pamirs, ritual cannabis in Judah, burned beside the Temple’s own signature spice. Doesn’t prove a chain of custody. Makes it very hard to wave off.

Eleven Ingredients — Eleven Effects?

Two ingredients don’t make this list. Onycha’s identity is genuinely disputed — mollusk, resin, gum, take your pick, the scholars can’t agree. Balsam has the same identity problem and, even under its best guess, no neuroactive pharmacology at all. I’d rather tell you that than force it.

Seven of eleven with real receptor-level activity, plus cannabis. That’s the actual evidence for whether the ketoret was a drug, not speculation. Not a spice rack. A stack.

GABA-A, opioid receptors, serotonin, TRPV3, CB1 — these systems talk to each other. Asking “is myrrh psychoactive” misses the point. The real question is what seven compounds, burned and inhaled together, do to a nervous system that none of them can do alone.

And here’s the one nobody’s explained: galbanum stops seizures. Real pharmacology. But nothing else in the formula carries convulsant risk — not the frankincense, not the cannabis. So what was it insurance against? The only candidate left is the one ingredient nobody was ever told the name of.

Wait — Two of These Showed Up at a Baby Shower

A few centuries later, a baby’s born in Bethlehem. Some astrologers show up — not three kings, Matthew never says three, never says kings, that’s a rumor that started seven hundred years later — and hand over gold, frankincense, and myrrh.

Two of which we’ve just spent several thousand words proving are neuroactive.

I want to be careful here, because this is exactly the leap that gets a guy in trouble. Nothing says the magi packed frankincense and myrrh because they knew what it did to a nervous system — gold-plus-frankincense was standard royal tribute; a Greek king gave the same combo to Apollo two centuries earlier. But read it as a shopping trip instead of a metaphor: the gold wasn’t just symbolic. It was the cash to keep buying more of exactly this stack. Either nobody knew what they had, or everybody did and nobody wrote it down. Worst, and most expensive, baby gift ever.

So What Was Ma’aleh Ashan?

Cannabis is now archaeologically shown to be in the right time and place. Ma’aleh ashan is described, in the Talmud itself, as whatever made the smoke rise. But its identity was guarded, then lost, and we still can’t equate the two as fact. That gap — not the conclusion — is exactly why “was the ketoret a drug” doesn’t have a clean yes or no yet. It’s where the real investigation lives.

Identify the candidates. Reconstruct the 368-maneh proportions at scale. Model the combustion. See what survives the burn and reaches a priest breathing it in an enclosed stone room, with and without cannabis in the mix. This isn’t unanswerable. It’s untested.

The Rasayana Stack: Ashwagandha and the Medhya Quartet

India built the same kind of stack for a completely different reason: not communion, just a longer, clearer life.

Ashwagandha’s whole root extract genuinely activates GABA-A receptors — lab-confirmed in 2015 — but neither of its two most-studied compounds does it alone when tested individually. Nobody’s found the actual active ingredient yet. Same open question as spikenard.

It was never handed out solo, either. Charaka names a specific quartet to run with it — Mandukaparni, Guduchi, Shankhapushpi, Yashtimadhu — and between the five, they cover almost the whole GABA system plus one mechanism the ketoret never touches: Yashtimadhu doesn’t hit a receptor at all, it just makes your own cortisol last longer. It’s also the one ingredient in this whole piece with a real safety ceiling — chronic high doses cause documented hypertension.

Dosing isn’t folklore: the trial behind Ashwagandha’s sleep and anxiety data used 300mg twice daily for ten weeks — right in the range a 2022 psychiatric taskforce now recommends. The classical version just asks for a teaspoon of powder simmered in warm milk.

And here’s the part worth sitting with if this site is about consciousness at all: nobody’s run “Ashwagandha plus actual meditation” as a study. But acute doses measurably prevent mental fatigue and preserve sustained attention on vigilance tasks. Charaka classified this whole quartet by three faculties — Dhi, Dhriti, Smriti — grasping, retention, recall. Dhriti in particular is uncomfortably close to a working definition of concentration itself. The modern data and the seventeen-century-old classification are pointing at the same thing. Nobody’s tested whether it makes the actual sitting better. That’s the honest gap, and maybe the next real question.

Six traditions. Five of them chasing God. Rasayana chases a clearer mind instead — same engineered logic, no god required.

Which means the real discovery here was never religious. It was pharmacology, and religion was just the delivery system most civilizations happened to reach for. Eliade called this humanity’s archaic technology of ecstasy. He was mostly writing about drums and dancing. He might have missed that some of it was never about ecstasy at all.

Was the Ketoret a Drug? The Honest Answer

Probably, in part. Certainly engineered like one. The eleven-ingredient formula, the guarded twelfth compound, the receptor-level science on seven of the eleven, the insane cost sustained for centuries, the testing methodology hiding in plain sight in the Talmud — none of that reads like decoration. It reads like a technology whose engineers never wrote down the one part that mattered most, and in these quantities the priests might have needed rehab; nobody should smoke that much!

QP

Further Reading

On this site:

What Were They Smoking Before Tobacco? →

The Technologies of Ecstasy Hub →

The Happiness Prescription →

The primary sources behind was the ketoret a drug, free and in full:

• Moussaieff A, et al. “Incensole acetate, an incense component, elicits psychoactivity by activating TRPV3 channels in the brain.” FASEB Journal, 2008. →
• Dolara P, et al. “Analgesic effects of myrrh.” Nature, 379, 29 (1996). →
• Razack S, et al. “Anxiolytic actions of Nardostachys jatamansi via GABA benzodiazepine channel complex mechanism.” Metabolic Brain Disease, 33(5), 2018. →
• Sayyah M, Mandgary A, Kamalinejad M. “Evaluation of the anticonvulsant activity of the seed acetone extract of Ferula gummosa Boiss.” Journal of Ethnopharmacology, 82, 2002. →
• Okugawa H, et al. “Effect of dehydrocostus lactone and costunolide from Saussurea root on the central nervous system in mice.” Phytomedicine, 3(2), 1996. →
• Nguyen LTH, et al. “Anxiolytic-like Effect of Inhaled Cinnamon Essential Oil and Its Main Component Cinnamaldehyde in Animal Models.” Molecules, 27(22), 2022. →
• Ren M, et al. “The origins of cannabis smoking: Chemical residue evidence from the first millennium BCE in the Pamirs.” Science Advances, 5(6), 2019. →
• Arie E, Rosen B, Namdar D. “Cannabis and Frankincense at the Judahite Shrine of Arad.” Tel Aviv, 47(1), 2020. →
• Antonopoulos R, et al. “Investigating the psychedelic hypothesis of kykeon, the sacred elixir of the Eleusinian Mysteries.” Scientific Reports, 16, 8757 (2026). →
• Candelario M, et al. “Direct evidence for GABAergic activity of Withania somnifera on mammalian ionotropic GABAA and GABAρ receptors.” Journal of Ethnopharmacology, 171, 264–272 (2015). →
• Kale S, Lopresti A, Suri R, Garg N, Langade D. “Safety and Efficacy of Ashwagandha Root Extract on Cognition, Energy and Mood Problems in Adults.” Journal of Psychoactive Drugs, 2024. →
• Sarma DN, Khosa RL, Chansauria JP, Sahai M. “Antistress activity of Tinospora cordifolia and Centella asiatica extracts.” Phytotherapy Research, 10(2), 181–183 (1996). →
• Awad R, Levac D, Cybulska P, Merali Z, Trudeau VL, Arnason JT. “Effects of traditionally used anxiolytic botanicals on enzymes of the gamma-aminobutyric acid (GABA) system.” Canadian Journal of Physiology and Pharmacology, 85(9), 933–942 (2007). →